T-Mobile G1 or Samsung Behold

I'm trying to figure out which phone to get next. I still have a year on my T-mobile contract so going to another provider isn't an option since I need to get a new phone soon. Which one should I get?T-Mobile G1 or Samsung Behold
according to PCpro, the G1 is not particularly good. The 'android' phone concept is good, but the actual G1 itself is not very good, so, i would not recommend that.,T-Mobile G1 or Samsung Behold
it all comes down to if you like touch screen or actual qwerty



so id choose based on that



EDIT

and the behold does not have WiFi
Why don't you just finish up the contract and see what new phones are out by then?
I'm on family plan with my wife. She won't ever get rid of T-mobile so she keeps renewing our contract for 2 years at a time. My phone currently (Sidekick 3) has deleted my phonebook list 3 times. So I'm just going to get a phone i really like if I have to stick with T-mobile. I just can't choose between the Behold and the G1, since I like them both.
Get the G1. The Samsung is a nice phone too, but the only thing it has going for it is the 5 Megapixel camera. The G1 is a better ''future proof'' phone because of its incredible OS, Android. You can get Apps and new features and can customize every aspect of the phone. The Behold's OS is your run of the mill Samsung OS which youll feel like chucking away after a year.
I dont really know which one is better...cant say